Choosing Between Mould Type and Band Type Spiral Tubeformers: A Comprehensive Comparison

Choosing Between Mould Type and Band Type Spiral Tubeformers: A Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to producing spiral ducts for HVAC systems, manufacturers face a crucial decision:

whether to invest in a mould type spiral tubeformer or a band type spiral tubeformer.

Understanding the differences between these two machines can help you make an informed choice based on durability,

convenience, price, and overall functionality.

1.

Durability

Durability is a significant factor to consider for manufacturers, and feedback from customers consistently

highlights the advantage of mould-type formers over band-type formers.

Many users report that band-type machines, particularly those from lesser-known brands,

tend to turn into scrap more quickly due to material fatigue and wear.

In contrast, mould-type machines, especially those from reputable manufacturers such as Spiro, are noted for their robustness and longevity.

Customers who transitioned to mould-type formers have seen remarkable improvements,

enjoying the machines' efficient functioning over extended periods without significant issues.

This durability translates to less frequent downtime and repair costs, making mould type formers a more reliable investment in the long run.

2.

Convenience

Convenience is another important consideration when choosing a spiral tubeformer.

Mould-type machines generally require operators to change moulds to modify forming diameters.

While this might seem cumbersome, once the moulds are changed, the machine continues to perform at a high level of efficiency and consistency.

On the other hand, band-type machines allow for some flexibility in adjusting the forming diameter without the need to change out entire moulds.

However, while this aspect might provide a slight edge in convenience, it does not significantly outweigh the overall benefits provided by mould-type formers in terms of performance and finished product quality.

3.

Price

Price is often a decisive factor in purchasing equipment.

Mould-type spiral tubeformers typically have a higher upfront cost; our current pricing for a complete set is around USD 17,500, which includes five sets of moulds.

If additional moulds are required for different diameters, the cost ranges between USD 400 and USD 850, depending on the size.

In comparison, the band-type spiral tubeformer generally costs around USD 13,500 per set, making it a less expensive option initially.

However, it's essential to consider that the lower purchase price may lead to higher maintenance costs and potentially reduced longevity, resulting in more frequent replacements or repairs.

Ultimately, the choice between mould-type and band-type spiral tubeformers hinges on specific business needs and production goals.

•If you prioritize durability, quality, and long-term reliability, the mould-type former is the superior choice.

• While it comes with a higher initial investment, the potential for greater lifespan, lower downtime, and overall efficiency make it a worthwhile expenditure.

•If upfront costs are your primary concern, and you are willing to accept potential trade-offs in durability and quality, you might consider the band-type spiral tubeformer.

• However, keep in mind the feedback from other users who have found greater satisfaction and performance longevity in mould-type machines.

For manufacturers looking to invest in a high-quality, reliable spiral duct fabrication setup, the mould-type spiral tubeformer emerges as the most favorable option.

We welcome your thoughts and experiences on this subject.

What machine do you think would best suit your needs? Share your views and let us know! Thank you!